On March 27, FLH attorneys Brian Malkin and Christopher Gosselin attended the International Trade Commission (“ITC”) Trial Lawyer’s Association (“ITCTLA“) luncheon with administrative law judge (“ALJ”) Thomas B. Pender. Judge Pender joined the ITC in October, 2011, and is one of six ALJs at the Commission.
Judge Pender arrived at the luncheon with a number of themes that he wanted to discuss. Chief among them is a concern shared by many other ALJs and district court judges about the scope of electronic discovery in today’s litigation. He urged the practitioners in the room not to lose control of the paper, and to reign in the costs and scope of electronic discovery. In Pender’s experience, less than 1% of all discovery becomes an exhibit, and less than 5% of those exhibits are ever argued. In addition to paring back discovery, Pender would like to see fewer patents and patent claims being asserted by complainants. Ultimately, Pender would like to see more efforts taken to reduce the cost of litigation at the ITC, and hopes that more streamlined cases will allow him to finish an Initial Determination in a year or less.
Judge Pender also suggested, on a related note, that big firms make an effort to send their associates “to the podium,” both to give the associates valuable experience, and to reduce the cost of a trial. In his experience, well-prepared associates perform as well or better than partners who had less time to prepare. Pender cautioned parties to think twice before betting an entire case on one witness, and suggested that secondary witnesses could and should be handled by associates.